14 Dark Rum Cocktails to Try at Home This Year

October 20, 2023 by Anna-Bet Stemmet

Jump to:

Dark rum cocktails are the little black dress of the DIY cocktail scene – they are super versatile and very easy to pull off. You can dress them up, dress them down, or easily invent a whole new vibe with the addition of a few choice accessories. Here’s everything you need to know about experimenting with this diverse (and super tasty!) spirit.  

What sets dark rum apart?

Close up of a snifter of dark rum in a still life set-up with ship's rope, a bottle of dark rum and a spoked wheel in the background

Dark rum is known for its rich flavour profile, dark colour, and often a more robust and complex taste compared to lighter rums. There are several factors that contribute to what makes dark rum special: 

Ageing process. Dark rums are typically aged for a longer period in wooden barrels. The ageing process allows the rum to absorb flavours from the wood, resulting in a more complex and nuanced taste. The barrels may be made from different types of wood, such as oak, which further influences the final flavour. 

Caramelised sugar or molasses. Dark rum is often made from molasses or caramelised sugar, which gives it a darker colour and contributes to its distinct taste. The use of these ingredients adds depth and richness to the flavour profile. 

Flavour complexity. Due to the longer ageing process and the use of specific ingredients, dark rum tends to have a more complex flavour profile. You might find notes of caramel, vanilla, toffee, spice, and sometimes even hints of chocolate or coffee. The combination of these flavours makes it a popular choice for sipping and for use in cocktails. 

Warmth and smoothness. Dark rum is often appreciated for its smoothness and warmth. The ageing process helps mellow the spirit, and the result is a drink that is often perceived as smoother and more comforting. 

Versatility. While dark rum is enjoyable on its own, it is also a versatile spirit that can be used in various cocktails. It adds depth and character to drinks, making it a favourite in classic cocktails like the Mai Tai, Dark ‘n Stormy, and the Rum Punch. 

Cultural significance. Dark rum is often associated with certain regions and cultural traditions. For example, Jamaican and Caribbean rums are well-known for their dark varieties. The production methods and the specific characteristics of the local ingredients contribute to the uniqueness of these rums. 

It’s important to note that not all dark rums are the same, and there can be variations in flavour based on factors such as the distillation process, the type of barrels used, and the specific ingredients used by different distilleries. This diversity is part of what makes exploring and enjoying dark rum an interesting and enjoyable experience for enthusiasts. 

Here are a few of our favourite cocktails with dark rum to try at home:  

1. Dark ‘n Stormy

Dark ‘n Stormy Recipe

Dark rum cocktail recipes do not come any more classic than the Dark ‘n Stormy. With a storied history that harks back more than a century, it’s a thirst-quencher of note that is best enjoyed with your toes in the sand. However, it will get you in a tropical state of mind even if you happen to be slap-bang in the middle of a concrete jungle.  

2. Rum Punch

A top view of Rum Punch that is ideal to make for batching cocktails

Making dark rum cocktails at home to serve to a crowd? Then Rum Punch is your answer, friend! It comes together very easily and goes down smoothly on a hot day – perfect for pool parties, BBQs, and sunny days. We love pairing it with snacks like coconut shrimp, jerk chicken, and ceviche served with crunchy nacho chips.  

Read next: 11 Caribbean Cocktails that Serve Major Vacay Energy 

3. Rum Runner

Close up of a Rum Runner cocktail garnished with pineapple and a slice of orange

Arguably one of the best dark rum cocktails around, the Rum Runner is fruity and juicy to the core, and when made with dark rum, takes on deeper and richer flavour notes that round it off most deliciously. It’s absolutely wonderful served with seafood dishes like fish tacos and tropical sushi rolls.  

4. Painkiller

Two creamy Painkiller cocktails with fresh orange garnish

Easy dark rum cocktails for effortless sipping? Meet the Painkiller. This classic cocktail is a decidedly smooth and tropical drinking experience. The combination of dark rum, pineapple juice, orange juice, and cream of coconut creates a rich and creamy texture. The molasses undertones of the rum blend seamlessly with the fruity notes, and the nutmeg garnish adds a hint of spice, adding a beautiful bit of balanced warmth at the end.   

You might also like: 15 of the Best Tiki Cocktails 

5. Navy Grog

A Navy Grog with a lime

Simple dark rum cocktails do not come any tastier than the Navy Grog. The story goes that the original Grog was created to help sailors fight scurvy on long sea voyages, but the Navy Grog recipe that we enjoy today was created during the height of Tiki culture and was served at Donn Beachcomber bars across California. Made with three types of rum, fresh citrus, honey syrup, and soda, it’s a potent drink that’s best sipped at leisure. 

6. Mai Tai

Refreshing boozy Mai Tai cocktail on the rocks with cherry and pineapple garnish

If you love easy dark rum cocktails with some serious tropical swagger, the Mai Tai should be at the top of your list. This rum-forward drink comes to the party with hints of sweet orange liqueur and a subtle tartness from the lime juice. You can also easily scale this recipe into a crowd-pleaser by making a pitcher in advance. Combine all ingredients (except the ice) and chill in the fridge before serving. 

Caribbean Inspiration: 10 Falernum Cocktails to Try 

7. Black Manhattan

Little Italy Cocktail

The Black Manhattan recipe is a Gen Z baby invented in 2005 by bartender Todd Smith. A seductive caramel-tinged riff on the classic, it features the Italian amaro, Averna, which replaces the sweet vermouth in the traditional Manhattan recipe. This adds even more depth and character to this already complex cocktail. 

8. Mojito with Dark Rum

Close up of two glasses of Mojito with Dark Rum on a table overlooking an oceanscape beyond on a clear and sunny day

A Dark Rum Mojito offers a robust twist on the classic. Dark caramel notes from the rum mingle with the lime’s citrusy kick, creating a harmonious depth. Muddled mint releases a refreshing aroma, while simple syrup adds a touch of sweetness. The result is a balanced amalgamation of bold flavours, with the dark rum providing a warm undertone that complements the cocktail’s crisp, minty freshness 

Check this out! The Ultimate List of 2-Ingredient Rum Drinks 

9. Jungle Bird

Jungle Bird cocktail with fresh pineapple wedge garnish

The Jungle Bird cocktail is such a showstopper, it’s no wonder it’s Malaysia’s national drink. While it contains Campari, it differs from the classically bitter cocktails like the Negroni, as the Jungle Bird cocktail recipe makes for a much more saccharine sip. With caramel tones of rum, sweet pineapple juice, and fresh lime, this drink is perfect for those who enjoy a sweeter drink. 

10. Hot Buttered Rum

Glass of brown buttered rum cocktail wiht cinnamon

This Hot Buttered Rum recipe is a time-honored holiday staple that dates back centuries. Irresistibly warm and sweet, it is perfect for wintery get-togethers when you want to serve up the ultimate indulgence and everyone is craving a fragrantly cosy drink. 

11. Hurricane

Three Hurrican Cocktails on a tray

A Hurricane cocktail offers a lively burst of bold tropical flavours. Dark and light rum create a dynamic base, their richness tempered by passion fruit and orange juices. Grenadine adds a touch of sweetness, while a hint of lime provides a subtle tartness. It’s a whirlwind of bold, fruity notes with a pleasing depth of rummy goodness.  

12. Piña Colada

A Pina Colada cocktail on a table next to a deck chair overlooking the ocean on a sunny day

When made with dark rum, the Piña Colada gains extra velvety richness. The deep, molasses-infused notes of dark rum combine seamlessly with the creamy coconut and sweet pineapple in a tropical embrace with a subtle complexity, and a warm and inviting undertone. The result is a luscious cocktail that maintains the refreshing allure of the original while offering a deeper, more nuanced flavour profile. 

13. Zombie

Two Zombie cocktails with lime wheel garnish

A Zombie cocktail is a potent fusion of light and dark rum, lime juice, pineapple juice, and grenadine. The boldness of rum harmonises with the bright fruity notes of the juice, resulting in a spirited cocktail with layers of flavour. Sip slowly and enjoy! 

14. Old Cuban

Old Cuban Cocktail

Making an Old Cuban with dark rum is a fabulous affair. The deep notes of dark rum intertwine with the sparkle of Champagne, and bitters add a subtle spice, while mint leaves contribute a refreshing herbal touch. It’s a refined and timeless clinker, with the dark rum’s depth serving to elevate the effervescence of the Champagne. 


For cocktails, it's ideal to choose a dark rum with rich, complex flavours. Look for well-balanced options like those aged in oak barrels for depth. Popular choices include Jamaican or Caribbean dark rums, known for their robust profiles. Experiment with different brands to find one that complements your preferred cocktails, whether it's a classic Mai Tai or a Dark 'n Stormy.

Stay in the mix

Sign up to our drinkspiration newsletter.